Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sandra's avatar

Whitney, you did it again. You shouted your truth out loud! Not worrying about one damn thing. BPD is tough. But you? You are tougher! Bravo! 💕

Expand full comment
Jennifer N. Haddock's avatar

“Borderline is not a personality disorder. Borderline is a grief disorder.” Well said, all of it! As a Radical Behaviorist, we see psychiatric disorders as ways to categorize behavior that doesn’t fit the mold, using the medical model of pathology. I’m not big on this practice or diagnostic labels for what is ultimately just behavior, though getting a diagnosis can lead to getting help fitting into and accepting a broken system. But the “personality disorders” class of diagnoses has always rubbed me the wrong way. “Personality” is just a way to classify behavioral patterns, all of which are acquired and maintained by the external environment. The obvious problem with the personality diagnoses is that they’re saying “these patterns are your fault; something is wrong with you.” And that doesn’t help the person or point to the true causes that could be addressed, especially when it comes to “BPD.” Also, like you said, “Borderline” is disproportionately diagnosed in females, which suggests there are common experiences that lead to similar behavioral patterns amongst females, or that the “disorder” is based on women behaving outside the lines of a male-defined culture. And the alternative “emotional regulation disorder” isn’t much better. I’ve heard it suggested that, many times, “borderline” is ADHD and/or Autism + CPTSD, which makes sense if you’re tied to the medical model. But, I am not keen on pathologizing behavior as a problem of the brain or inner workings. I think you’re onto something with grief and trauma, and wanting to be loved for who you are (rather than who you’re being, for them). I do not have this diagnosis but I relate to some of the things you said here: the grief of not being loved or seen, trauma, or an environment that has lots of punishment and aversive control, emotional responding when people don’t reply, getting attached and loving too hard when someone finally sees you (until they inevitably leave, too). In short, I loved this piece. Thank you. “It looks like slowly, painstakingly, building an internal self that can hold your own pain instead of outsourcing it to others.” 💕 I’m just not sure that’s possible without others.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts